A Worthy Worship 7 : A Dramatic God

“No eye has seen, no ear has heard, no mind has conceived what God has prepared for those who love him” – Paul (1 Corinthians 2:9) (From imgsrc.hubblesite.org) The respective cores of the twin galaxies are the orange blobs, left and right of image center, crisscrossed by filaments of dark dust. A wide band of chaotic dust, called the overlap region, stretches between the cores of the two galaxies. The sweeping spiral- like patterns, traced by bright blue star clusters, shows the result of a firestorm of star birth activity which was triggered by the collision.

We all love drama. From the stories told us as children, to books we learned to read, to an appreciation for the theatre, to the sensory fullness of film, to virtual reality computer games, the insatiable appetite for news stories, to the voyeuristic pleasure we get from gossip, we all love drama. In fact, we seem to need it. There is after all no worse fate than boredom.We human beings are in fact, creatures of drama.  

Some of us will have realised that our own lives, too, are suffused with all kinds of unexpected twists and turns, full of surprise, if we have taken the opportunity to read them. It is often when we allow ourselves to be read by others that we discover them. If we take the time and care we will see no end to the drama in the lives of others. But the pleasure of these readings will not come without hard work and often, excruciating pain. There are many who never have and never will, discover the exquisite narratives of their own lives. There is no cheap way to enter into these less obvious dramas.   

And yet I suspect that these Hidden Dramas are in fact the real story. They are what we ought to be focusing on. But in order to appropriate this, we shall need to take a hard, critical look at the claims of the more obvious stories which claim our allegiance day in and day out.  We are in context discussing Worthy Worship. By this we mean first and foremost having a view of the object of our worship that does not devalue it. 

So here is an assertion: as worshipping beings, we worship a Dramatic God. It is appropriate then that our work of worship be filled with drama. It is inappropriate that what we call worship is in any way bored, dull, tedious, devoid of depth. And yet so often it is. Let us try then to define what makes up this drama. To start, what is it not, or what prevents us from perceiving it. I suggest 4 possibilities: 

First, just like the poetic does not mean poetry, drama is not synonymous with theatre. It is much broader than that. I am in no ways against Film and Theatre, in fact I deeply respect these arts and their practitioners, but we need to be wary of seeing drama as being the domain of specialists, for in so doing we rob ourselves of our role in the drama of life. Drama should be entertaining, yes, but it is not about entertainment, but participation.

Secondly, drama is not sensationalism. When we call something dramatic, it’s usually used as “A dramatic turn of events” in the context of a media news item, or “Don’t be so dramatic” when talking to a petulant child. The establishment has commoditised the dramatic so that it has become something we are fed by CNN or Sky, by Disney or Universal, by any printed or published media concern who needs to hold our attention for their very survival. At worst, tabloid publications deem themselves to hold the moral high ground on the tackiest of topics, in the most expedient and whimsical ways so as to assuage their readership’s gaping lack of personal responsibility, morality or creativity. In both of these ways, the effect of defining drama as theatre or film, and of commoditising it, means that the view that we do not partake in it is reinforced. They are the actors, the anchormen, the journalists, or authors, and we, the passive consumers. 

Thirdly, anthropomorphism, human centric ideas of time and space, will rob us of most drama. We only sense a very limited range of frequencies, for example light and sound waves. Our natural facilities in themselves will not perceive all that is going on. Certain technologies and sciences like astronomy and quantum physics help us to view events on a scale altogether different to what is available to the natural eye or ear. Viewing galaxies colliding millions of years ago. Or observing how unpredictable sub atomic particles can be. 

Forth, and perhaps the single most limiting factor preventing us from entering into the drama of Life, is the absence of imagination and faith in transcending our human-centric points of view. Without imagination we can never tap into the bigger picture. One of the most profound writings on this comes from the unknown writer of Book of Hebrews:  “Now faith is being sure of what we hope for and certain of what we do not see. This is what the ancients were commended for. By faith we understand that the universe was formed at God’s command, so that what is seen was not made out of what was visible.” 

One comment that needs to be offered is that it is important for us to see that although the universe was “Formed at God’s command”, this does not preclude the fact that creation continues; all creation accounts have a beginning point, but many also have an end point in the past. It is my belief that the word “Creation” is a verb in the present tense, not a noun. 

So the ultimate drama, then, is this: the ongoing act of creation. The one whom we worship is not merely creative; G-d is the Creator from whom all emanates: the whole universe, all life and creativity. There is infinity of dramas, if only we could apprehend them. The story of the Earth, what the ants are doing on a branch, how a relationship changes over the years, how communities come together and are torn apart, how my inner journey has progressed when I look back on it… these are the dramas to which I allude. 

So based on these cosmic assertions, what are the implications for us mortals, bound up as we are in the 21st century with all our tiny woes and concerns? Drama involves characters, situations and narrative. If we can extend the notion of the “priesthood of all believers” we can also say the “dramatic company of all believers”. Like the clergy-laity dualism which was exploded but not destroyed by the work of those such as Martin Luther, we are in a position to tear down the dualism that exists between Actors and Audience.  

It is not wrong to at times be in the audience, for observing is a key discipline. Watching or listening can be every bit as active as performing. But it would not be becoming to a Dramatic God or a Creation suffused with Drama to always be on the sidelines. A key to being an Actor on the stage of creation is that an incarnation is taking place. Unlike a Moviegoer or Virtual Reality user, the drama takes place both in and around the Actor.

The best attempts by Film, Game or Theatre to envelope the audience with the sensory will never bring that consumer into the Drama of Creation in any profound way. Even radical attempts to interact directly with the neural networks in the brain via implanted electronics or psychological drugs, will forever fail to bring the user-consumer into the presence of G-d. Of course this is an interesting discussion which should be ongoing, and a talking point on the leading edge of biotech and information technology, but my personal view is that these paths do not lead us to the essence of being, or to G-d. 

It can be said that the Central Drama of Creation is the Eucharist. Here is the story of the Creator of the Cosmos coming to earth as human, willingly dying to meet the law of God, and defeating death. If it wasn’t for the tremendous weight of habit, prejudice and Christian malpractice, everyone might agree that the story of the Incarnation is the greatest, and possibly, the original story of our lives. Yet so few do the story of God in Jesus justice, for they are waylaid by the very things we have discussed above in what inhibits us from truly entering the Creation’s great and enduring Story. 

(From Wikipedia) On this canvas, Saul is an epileptic and fractured figure, flattened by the divine flash, flinging his arms upward in a funnel. There are three figures in the painting. The commanding muscular horse dominates the canvas, yet it is oblivious to the divine light that defeated his rider's gravity. The aged groom is human, but gazes earthward, also ignorant of the moment of where God intervenes in human traffic. Only Saul, whose gravity and world has been overturned lies prostrate and supine on the ground, but facing heaven, arms supplicating rescue. The groom can see his shuffling feet, and the horse can plod its hooves, measuring its steps; but both are blind to the miracle and way.The word epiphany has a special, sacred significance. It is a fundamental revelation, a change of awareness in ones life which might only come but a few times to us during our lifetimes. One of the most drama-filled epiphanies we know of is the conversion of Saul, captured in the 1601 painting by the Italian master Caravaggio pictured on the right.

But let us with seemingly lesser tales of encounters with truth take heart, we can all in our own way enter the divine drama.  The Dramatically aware worshiper is one who will do justice to a Dramatic Creator and a Dramatic Creation. They are best placed to explore the Incarnation, and the infinity of possibilities lying around and inside them. So long as they really believe, that “No eye has seen, no ear has heard, no mind has conceived what God has prepared for those who love him”, to mean, not that we cannot know what is prepared for us, but that it is so vast that none will be able to exhaust the generosity and scope of its offering.

Published by Nic Paton

Composer of music for film, television and commercials.

9 thoughts on “A Worthy Worship 7 : A Dramatic God

  1. Well I would like to comment on this. Firstly I got a bit lost which put me in a sermonic state (as in stitting with my head in my hands on a pew next to devoted others). I did wonder whether you have sat through one too many bad sermons and have finally got to the point of saying “Hey I can do this”. Well you do it well and many a floor of worshipers could do a lot worse than to digest this food you offer.

    I believe that in our age the phenomenon of the intermediary is what often removes us from the source of things and consequently the drama. To find authentic drama can sometimes be as simple as bypassing an intermediary. Go milk a cow, grow your own vegetables, cut a piece of wood, see and touch your dead loved one. In fact I believe the more authentic role of the intermediary / mediator (often in the form of performing art, live or canned) is to take people to their drama rather than facilitate some vicarious existence that removes them from it and “does it for them”. This is where the church so often misses the plot, I beleive. As artists I believe it is important to understand this. And that takes me to my currently evolving blog on the phenomenon of the intermediary. Coming soon…

    As for chemically facilitated experiences. Do you include drug induced altered states? This is one of the most common vehicles shamen use to access drama on a level that is likely to undo most of us. Future blog – “a being in a box”. Have you thought about the role of the shaman in mediating the drama of creation. The idea just occurred to me. I’ll have to think about what I actually mean.

  2. as always, a deep & generous post. the vision that is unfolding on your blog begs the question in my mind: how to enact or manifest this in real life, especially in the life of a church fellowship?

    since moving to a new town 4 years ago, we decided to engage a local church but it wasn’t long before boredom and a feeling of having to leave the majority of ourselves at the door set in. creation does seem to suggest that we seek and worship a dramatic G-d and yet i find myself intensely bored with and dis-engaged from worship within a church context.

    and yet a walk in the hills behind our house resurrects these seemingly lost or dormant urges. the grand old churches and cathedrals were partly created to raise us beyond the mundane and yet my recent foray into “fellowship” has left me saying “SNAFU” – “situation normal, all ****ed up”.

    viva all of you who seek a worthy worship of a dramatic G-d.

  3. There seems to be a time for withdrawing due to SNAFU, and a time for invigoration and vision. The more you spiral “around the block upwards” the more generous your point of view, therefore you can better weigh up the risk of embarking on a “ridiculous” venture of imagination and faith.

    I know the state only too well whereby one just does not want to engage the church with all her handbags, shopping and suitcases, all that baggage. It’s at those times I yearn to be tucked away in a monastry or like you just roam the hills and commune with G-d.

    But at times liked this I can’t help but feel there is a way to address the boredom and experience a small foretaste of this much-cliched, much-sentimentalised, “Glory”.

  4. Nic.

    i agree with you. the hills/forest/monastic options have their place but engagement with the church in some form – seeking the “mystical unity” that Bruce Cockburn so beautifully described – seems a worthwhile persuit. i see u fleshing out a “how to?” approach on your blog.

    ruZL.

  5. Nic,

    Great post. I can’t think of a reply right now, but I do have a couple questions. How would you define anthropomorphism? In what ways do you think it can be negative?

    Light

  6. Hello Light
    Good observation; I think anthropocentric is what I was intending to say.

    What I mean by anthropomorphic/centric is a narrow view of life and the cosmos in which we limit ourselves to the human scale or human perception, and where the so-called ‘observable’ universe dictates what is actually going on. There is a lot more to life than ‘meets the eye’. So it is negative in that is limiting.

    Thanks again for taking the time here.

  7. Hey Nic,

    Sorry I missed the day that you posted this. It is quite provocative, a truly original and creative way to see the Creator. On deep, Jungian Archetypical levels, we humans are enacting the story of our culture. Change the story, change the context in which life is viewed.

    I am going to have to write a whoile post on this, and will link to you.

    BTW, Fox is still doing The Cosmic Mass.

    http://www.thecosmicmass.com/

  8. “It is appropriate then that our work of worship be filled with drama. It is inappropriate that what we call worship is in any way bored, dull, tedious, devoid of depth.”

    I can so understand this notion. I don’t know if you understand the lack of drama of trying to pray in a foreign language (for me, Hebrew) but it is almost impossible to be dramatic when you have no idea what you are singing or praying. Some times it sounds dramatic or holy or magical, but most of the time it was simply by rote with little or no understanding.

    It wasn’t until the last few years that I found a place where the drama of each and every week’s activity (only partly due to its being in English) that I have been able to feel the drama you mention in your blog.

    As a result, I look forward to and consider services to be a highlight of my week. I think about what I have heard during the week and walking around humming the tunes and songs.

    In retrospect, I suppose humans really learn best and feel more from the dramatic and that is why our stories (Bible, Koran, Bhagavadgita, etc) are so very dramatic in the telling.

  9. Hi IN2L (Hey that rhymes with Yentl doesn’t it?)

    Your struggle for the dramatic where the tools (of language) are underdeveloped illustrate that to experience drama is no cheap thing. True Drama, drama which is Incarnate, comes at the price of a long commitment, in your case to leaning a language and culture.

    I have been a dedicated Musician for over 30 years, and its only now that I feel I am in some way prepared to excersise my gift with the appropriate depth.

    I am thankful that music can transcend the difficulies contained in other langages, everyone can participate in a melody, but to connect the tongue and heart in a foriegn language can take time.

    BTW Take heart; I don’t experience the drama I talk about. Yet.

Leave a reply to lightcontrast Cancel reply